Sunday, March 23, 2014

The Other Side of Hope


April is the cruellest month, breeding
Lilacs out of the dead land, mixing
Memory and desire, stirring
Dull roots with spring rain.

T.S.Eliot


Over the course of the past year, I have witnessed more tears and felt the heaviness of grief more often than ever before in my life. As a chaplain in a hospital, I have sat with patients and patients’ family members in the midst of crushing news time and time again. It is never easy no matter how much time we have to prepare ourselves for it. When it finally happens, when we finally receive the crushing news, it is always crushing whether we have an hour, a day, a week, or years to prepare for it.

Words like hope and hopelessness, vitality and despair, heaven and hell can easily remain little more than words among other words. They can easily remain metaphorical concepts that we move and manipulate in the course a sentence in order to formulate our grand theologies of hope and love. However, when such words remain nothing more than concepts, they are empty of any sort of concrete significance, and when they remain empty of concrete significance, they leave the speaker of such words as nothing more than a parrot repeating useless mantras while watching the rush of lava approach steadily after a volcanic eruption.

If our theological language never touches the ground, if our words never bespeak experience, then they will be as cute as children in the schoolyard discoursing about determination and courage. Those children are not necessarily speaking lies by any means, but when they speak of determination and courage, it is not the same in the least as when a sixty-seven year old migrant worker reflects on his life or when a fifty-four year old Chinese lady tells the story about when she moved to America when she was twenty-eight without knowing how she would begin her new life. When the migrant worker and the Chinese lady speak of determination and courage, their words are colored with their experience. They have a knowing look in their eyes. Determination and courage are not mere words to them. Determination is when that migrant worker would eat only one meal a day in order to save enough money to buy his children shoes so they could go to school and learn English. Courage is when that young Chinese girl got on the plane and did not turn back to her parents waving goodbye. Their words have real concrete significance.

These past months as a chaplain in a hospital I have felt, experienced the theological words so often used throughout my time in seminary. And I must admit that theological concepts such as resurrection have felt distant; victory has been far out of reach. In such moments – and they are many – what is the function of theology? I have asked myself this again and again. In a clinical context and more broadly in a medicated society, what is the role of theology? I have not yet arrived upon a fully satisfying answer. However, I do think that in order for there to be a satisfying answer, it must come in the form of language and narratives that are full of experience, full of concrete significance. It is only when such language and narratives are rich with experience and concrete significance that they will have the capacity to frame our hopeless situations with genuine hope-filled perspective. Imaginary lines do nothing for a bleeding portrait.